Trump, Xi and Putin’s Shenzhen face-to-face meeting proves that in-person summits still matter

Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Email

Much hangs in the balance as the presidents of the US, China and Russia meet at the Apec summit in Shenzhen. Will the meeting offer a beacon of hope or forewarn more global fallout?

Today’s trilateral summit between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin might be as significant as the Yalta Conference in 1945, in which the three great Allies carved up the world map after the Second World War. But it could just as easily be a repeat of Anchorage: Trump and Putin’s meaningless meet-and-greet in Alaska last year.

The context of economic discussion is what lubricates this particular ménage à trois. Xi is not hosting his counterparts in Beijing – a setting that would lend a political overtone – but in Shenzhen. This week, China’s tech hub is dazzling crowds with laser-light shows and more than 100 Fortune 500 CEOs have flown into the city. Interestingly, the roster for the summit comprises “member economies” rather than states, so Hong Kong and Taiwan are able to participate. But the frenzy will reach a crescendo today as the leaders of China, Russia and the US retreat from the city to the Qilin Mountain Villa: a location that feels markedly different from San Francisco, Lima and Busan, which hosted the past three bilateral Asia-Pacific Economic Co-operation (Apec) summits with Xi.

We will find out what occurs within those walls in a few hours’ time. But one thing that we can be certain of is that the buzz around the summit is a major win for the Apec forum, which, for more than 30 years, has put a date on the calendar for world leaders on both sides of the Pacific. While Russia has been ostracised from the Arctic Council, the G7 and the World Economic Forum, Apec’s central premise – that economic interests can override geopolitical conflict – is proving increasingly prescient in a fractious time.

Trump, Xi and Putin
Good things come in threes? Trump, Xi and Putin show the importance of face value (Image: Iori Sagisawa/AFP via Getty Images)

Giving accused war criminal Vladimir Putin a seat at the table is a bitter pill to swallow for many in the West. But with so much at stake – from ending the wars in Ukraine and Iran to lowering global energy prices – the summit is a victory for those who view face-to-face meetings, even among adversaries, as worth the risk.

If the Shenzhen soirée goes well, perhaps Putin will accept the White House’s invitation to attend next month’s G20 summit in Miami. What Muscovite wouldn’t jump at the chance for some winter sunshine on South Beach? That said, Russian participation in previous meetings has already made for some uncomfortable moments. At last month’s forum in Atlanta, top G20 diplomats failed to reach a consensus on the war in Ukraine, choosing not to release a joint communiqué. Russian foreign-affairs minister Sergey Lavrov’s counterparts then declined to participate in the traditional “family photo”.

But if the G20 leaders that also hold Apec membership (Australia, Canada, Indonesia, Japan, Mexico and South Korea) can stomach sharing a stage with Russia in Shenzhen, then the prospect of a Miami boycott is less likely. Putin on US soil would likely produce winces in Ukraine and the EU but four years of diplomatic isolation hasn’t sent the Russian army packing for home. Could a tête-à-tête spark a change of course?

Much is riding on today’s pomp along the bucolic Xili Lake. Of course, there’s no guarantee of change but the possibility that the summit will cover significant ground is exciting. Will we, one day, hope for more summits such as Shenzhen 2026?

 

Related News